RevolutionZ
RevolutionZ
Ep 408 Liberating Theory Polity Plus Society As A Whole
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Episode 408 of RevollutionZ continues excerpting from the seven author book Liberating Theory. This time the episode is two chapters, one on the polity of society that follows those on kinship, cultural community, and economy, and the other on how all four together compose society as a whole.
How do political systems shape not only laws and policing, but also what feels “reasonable,” what counts as “responsible debate,” and which alternative possibilities will never even reach the table?
We consider the idea of the “single correct line” across regime types, from overt dictatorships that rely on fear and censorship to U.S. style representative democracy that relies on media filters, and control of resources for communication, and especially the socialization of communicators as they rise to visible positions. Along the way, we connect the “crisis of democracy” argument to a long-running pattern: when popular movements start to organize effectively, elites answer with a mix of repression and co-optation that is designed to rebuild apathy and narrow participation.
Then we widen the lens. Instead of treating society as driven by one master cause, we lay out the complementary holist view of society: economy, polity, kinship, and community are overlapping, entwined spheres that constantly interact. That approach leads to practical conceptual tools for activists, including “social moments,” "accommodation versus codefinition," and the idea of core characteristics that permeate everyday life. We finally push the framework to also include include ecology and international dynamics like imperialism, because any usable political theory has to match the real world we’re trying to change.
Each of the two chapters in this episode has its own associated dialogue in which our familiar array of participants, each with their own priorities and beliefs, discuss the ideas raised. Can the emerging framework appeal sufficiently to marxist, feminist, nationalist, anarchist, and also not yet deeply involved activists to generate a conversation to seek shared theory, strategy, and vision? You decide and perhaps alert others to the need to relate.
Welcome And Series Context
SPEAKER_00Hello, my name is Michael Albert, and I'm the host of the podcast that's titled Revolution Z. This is our 408th consecutive episode, and it returns to the sequence that excerpts from the seven author book titled Liberating Theory. This time the collective work addresses concepts for understanding polity and also society as a whole, with the aim to soon address how history unfolds and then finally vision and strategy. This excerpt begins.
What Politics Includes
SPEAKER_00Politics involves the creation of ideology, the setting of societal priorities, policies, laws, and regulations, and the conferring of power, whether with or without majority participation and ratification. The political sphere includes the state with its military, judiciary, police, legislature, and public works, political parties, lobbying and public interest organizations, etc. Depending on the specific character of the political sphere in a particular country, people may be hierarchically arrayed by elected or appointed office, bureaucratic tenure, military rank, party position, or unofficial backroom influence, as well as by economic, gender, and cultural factors rooted in the other spheres that we've discussed in prior episodes. People fall into different political hierarchies corresponding to different governing forms monarchy, parliamentary or US style representative democracy, military junta, one party dictatorship, one person dictatorship, and variations within these governing forms. Representative democracies may differ according to such factors as size and entrenchment of the state bureaucracy, voting frequency and procedures, extent of enfranchisement, number and nature of competing political parties, and access to and control over mass media.
Politics Shapes Freedom And Thought
SPEAKER_00Whatever form the state takes, political relations not only affect the distribution of governmental decision making power, but also the consciousness which people bring to the economic kinship and community spheres, and the freedom or lack of freedom that affects their ability to explore possibilities in those spheres. Political relations greatly affect the ways in which social institutions and structures mediate the dissemination of historical and contemporary information and misinformation, perceive the truth and the common good, and influence the parameters of public debate and individual thought itself. Politics isn't merely a reflection of other hierarchies within a dependent, unifying state. You can't understand authoritarianism in institutions and consciousness simply by extrapolating from class, gender, and community hierarchies. If the state is parliamentary, there will be one situation, but if it is dictatorial, there will be another. Whatever other defining features society may have, the political sphere, while it entwines with other defining spheres and feels their effects, also has a history and a set of dynamic attributes of its own that exert defining influences back upon the rest of society. For example, if the political sphere of a p of a particular society acts to continually repress dissent or to structurally co opt it, then this certainly will have an immense impact on dynamic relations and possibilities for change in all other spheres of social life, whatever their own intrinsic attributes and contradictions may be?
Why Regime Type Still Matters
SPEAKER_00Would anyone who denies this see no difference between living in a society with parliamentary democracy and one with a military dictatorship, all other social forms being otherwise fundamentally equal? Indeed, even given that two societies have formerly the same type of state, would anyone deny that great differences in the types of political movements and parties that vie for power in that society could also have dramatic impact on its citizens' quality and character of life? To understand any society, therefore, no single adjective describing a single sphere suffices. Politics arises from the need to balance and regulate disparate aims to attain collective ends. It deals with the organization of order, and attaining order often involves the attribution of authority either to individuals or impersonal bureaucracies. But when authority is vested in unyielding, unresponsive, or irresponsible hierarchy, it yields the political oppression we call authoritarianism by giving relatively few people excessive power at the expense of the many.
How Authority Turns Oppressive
SPEAKER_00Different types of authoritarian systems impose different restraints, oppressions, and opportunities on their citizens. Authoritarian regimes need not be dictatorships. They can incorporate procedural democracy as well. Authoritarianism is rationalized in a variety of ways, ordained by God, ethnicity, gender or racial superiority, paternalism, electoral mandate, national salvation, economic efficiency, elite competence, and so on. A primary characteristic of authoritarian political relations is a drive to find a single correct policy or line for any particular circumstance. A plurality of proposals may be debated, but regarding any particular problem, invariably only one proposal will be given authoritative sanction as either the divine wisdom of a few rulers or a compromise of larger elites. The notion of the quote correct line or quote common good is an essential tool for legitimating authoritarian rule. For example, in a US style representative democracy, decision makers gain legitimacy by asserting the need for efficiently centralizing decision making tasks in a central authority while promoting elected leadership as the most democratic way of balancing competing special interests and discerning the national interest.
Voting Without Real Control
SPEAKER_00Elite rhetoric focuses on the quote free choice involved in voting, while obscuring the separation of all actual decision making from the populace's will, oversight, or even awareness. There is no attention given to the fact that voters have little say in who runs for office and no power over what they do once they win office, even when elected officials ignore all campaign promises and platforms. Few would question the notion that the United States is a democracy, even though the U.S. government often does the opposite of what a majority of citizens demand. For example, a majority of U.S. citizens have been found to support the nuclear weapons freeze, national health insurance, extended environmental protection, and full employment. I interject. Please keep in mind throughout that liberating theory was published forty years ago.
Dictatorships And Fear Based Silence
SPEAKER_00The chapter continues in contrast, in a single party, quote Soviet style bureaucratic dictatorship, the party claims to represent popular sentiment and to distill it through the combined wisdom of society's most intelligent and committed leaders, its Communist Party cadre. The elite party members owe their position to their coercive power and to their claim to represent the combined quote scientific wisdom of all proletarians. They tolerate criticism no more than a doctor tolerates patients criticizing a prescription. In a dictatorship, the single correct quote truth prevails because no other thought can be broached publicly without risk of repression. In a military regime or repressive party dictatorship, people are generally allowed to form only those institutions of information exchange and social debate, unions, women's organizations, and other organizations that are sanctioned by the state. Where opposition organizations exist, they are subject to continual harassment and periodic wholesale repression. Voting is perfunctory, or where opposition candidates take part, fraud is used to manipulate the outcome. The media is censored directly or indirectly through a climate of fear. Subversive thoughts can and certainly will exist, but short of revolutionary upheavals, they will be kept effectively silent through fear of repression.
Soft Censorship In Democracies
SPEAKER_00In countries with legal rights of freedom of speech, press, etc., and the election of political representatives, the correct line is enforced differently. Indeed, the more quote democratic governing forms a political system has, the more its channels of communication and debate must operate within parameters which reinforce the assumptions of elites. Since there is little control over public expression of ideas, though there is plenty of control over the resources with which to communicate those ideas, for instance, access to television, university, tenure, etc., the formulation of the ideas themselves must be constrained. In other words, what is thinkable must be controlled so that when people manifest their rights of expression, they will rarely express thoughts subversive to defining cultural relations. Dissidents are, quote, red baited or ridiculed out of the quote responsible arena of debate and policy making. Whatever they're discussed with conditions in the US, people are more frightened of alternative images as filtered through the mass media and educational system. And in the words of E. E. Schatzschneider, the quote definition of alternatives is the supreme instrument of power. In the Soviet Union, news commentators can and no doubt sometimes do draw the personal conclusion that the Soviet invasion of Afghanistan is wrong and patriotic Soviet citizens should oppose the war and support the rebels. Moreover, such a commentator might even decide to say this over public media, as indeed one had. But he or she would then be quickly dispatched to an asylum, providing a healthy warning to others that they should keep their disturbing thoughts to themselves. In the US, however, although public news commentators could say almost anything on the air, risking only being fired and often not even that, none who have large audiences and have therefore risen through the ranks of conforming pressures can even manage to think a disturbing thought. Free to speak, they have little of import to say. For example, during the period of the Vietnam War, it was beyond their mental reach for any US press or mainstream TV commentator to even think that the US was the aggressor in Vietnam, and that the war should not only be opposed as a mistake, but American patriots should support the Vietnamese resistance.
Democracy As Elite Social Control
SPEAKER_00It follows that political systems incorporate democracy to roughly the degree that governing and other social authorities can be confident that it will be used as a form of social control to legitimate rather than undermine their interests. Stripped of genuine participation and dissent, democracy becomes a very worthwhile system for society's elites. It allows them to argue through their disagreements about how best to pursue their own interests and to simultaneously gauge popular reactions to alternative proposals they must judge. The subversive character of democracy is diminished as subordinate groups are disenfranchised and prevented from gaining access to information and means of developing and sharing alternative ideas and programs. Both these conditions operate magnificently in the US. And whenever popular forces do begin to emerge in ways that can translate and transmit information and ideas widely and serve as vehicles for dominated groups to develop subversive programs, a quote crisis of democracy ensues. And there is a turn toward repression to control the situation by destroying such forms and re engendering a passive citizenry. Keepers of the flame of democratic principle successfully reclaim their power from those who would quote destroy democracy by actually using it.
The Crisis Of Democracy Thesis
SPEAKER_00The clearest statement of the utilitarian purpose of limited or quote moderate democracy and the threat of an excess of democracy is found in the trilateral commission report, The Crisis of Democracy. The section on the United States was written by Samuel Huntington, the Harvard political scientist and sometime government official who praised the Vietnam War's quote forced urbanization program designed to rid the National Liberation Forces of a base of popular support in the countryside. Huntington wrote, quote, the effective operation of a democratic political system usually requires some measure of apathy and non involvement on the part of some individuals and groups. In itself, this marginality on the part of some groups is inherently undemocratic, but it is also one of the factors which has enabled democracy to function effectively. Of course, by quote some individuals and groups, Huntington means most. The quote crisis of democracy ensued in the sixties and seventies when, quote, previously passive or unorganized groups in the population, blacks, Indians, Chicanos, white ethnic groups, students and women now embarked on concerted efforts to establish their claim to opportunities, positions, rewards, and privileges which they had not considered themselves entitled to before. I interject. Readers in twenty twenty six will hopefully see that the current Trumpian and Fascist trends simultaneously embody and display both types of control, authoritarian and quote democratic, as the emerging fascist orientations try to replace the threatened quote democratic forms. This should evidence how these trends are, in their way, trying to fundamentally restructure society. And while the effort is most apparent in the political sphere, once attuned to the possibility, we can see its reach into cultural, kinship, and economic domains. The chapter continues. As with previous periods of mass protests in the US, the quote crisis of democracy in the sixties and seventies was answered with a mixed program of political repression, for instance the COINTEL programs, and co optation, for instance the anti poverty programs.
Repression And Co Optation In Practice
SPEAKER_00The media played a crucial role in reimposing apathy, with a constant drumdeat about the quote me decade of the later nineteen seventies, a time, of course, when the anti nuclear and gay liberation movements were, among others, on the ascent.
Anarchism And The Idea Of Hierarchy
SPEAKER_00Anarchism is the name given the broad movement of people who oppose authoritarianism in all its forms. Anarchists focused their attention firstly on hierarchies directly rooted in the structure and dynamics of the state, but then also extrapolate their concern for these political hierarchies to a derivative concern for other oppressions, such as economic exploitation, racism, or sexism, understanding each to be a manifestation of authoritarian hierarchy in another sector of daily life. For anarchists quote hierarchy becomes an organizing concept for all analysis as it permeates outward from the government to corrupt all aspects of life. As a goal, some anarchists elevate the idea of individualism, extolling the ultimate freedom and isolated integrity of each person in society. Other anarchists favor sociality, extolling the integrity and freedom of each individually only as all are part of an integrated social whole and socially responsible for one another's circumstances and well being. But all anarchists rightly argue that the political sphere projects forces which pervade all corners of society. The state rooted division of society doesn't stop at the executive, legislative, or judiciary door, since the role ingrained presuppositions of people in different positions in society's political hierarchies, whatever their exact form may be, permeate all other spheres of social life. State based hierarchies tend to reproduce all other social hierarchies by imposing them and also embodying their qualities. In Soviet style societies, for example, the political bureaucrat, party member, and average citizen confront different circumstances and options in all societies' institutions, not solely within the state. To rid society of any oppressions, state oppression must be overcome.
Where Anarchism Falls Short
SPEAKER_00Yet as valuable as these anarchist insights are, regrettably, some anarchists overextend their valid recognitions beyond their real range of influence. They label politics the sole defining sphere of social life. Implicitly, at least, they call the state's hierarchy society's base, the rest its superstructure. All oppressions become variants on state based authoritarianism. They analyze racism, sexism, and classism first in terms of analyses of states and their functions, in particular power and hierarchy, not first in terms of concepts rooted in the specific dynamics of those other spheres. They may ignore other spheres entirely, or alternatively, they may understand them, but only in the ways that they manifest specifically authoritarian relations, not in their own intricate and unique qualities. They see a hierarchy between men and women, blacks and whites, workers and bosses, and though they understand many of the emotive and material implications of such hierarchies, they fail to see all dimensions of the importance of the positive side of sexual interrelations, cultural definitions, and economic forms. They oppose marriage, religion, and complex large scale industry as necessarily status without understanding the more complex relations associated with each of these non government forms or the positive needs for security, continuity, spirituality, and material well being they speak to, which must also be addressed in any desirable future. The liberating thrust of anarchism, therefore, sometimes succumbs to a monus narrowness which forecloses fully understanding and effectively opposing all the forms of oppression which most anarchists in fact do wish to overcome. Change within the political sphere is most often evolutionary. Leaders come and go by election, appointment, or death. A new department of government is created, the military budget grows or shrinks, yet sometimes changes can grow to rupture old definitions and establish new ones. A sub elite rises to prominence and redefines governing relationships. A military coup throws out one state elite only to install another, equally oppressive, perhaps, but fundamentally different in its modes of operation. The impetus for evolutionary and revolutionary state change can arise from within the state, owing to changes in decision making perceptions or to conflicts between political groups, or from without, owing to economic, kinship or community pressures on political forms that cause their slight alteration or even their dissolution and redefinition. But we can only conceptualize these matters more fully in the context of a broader discussion of society and history in coming chapters. I interject. That ended the fifth chapter proper of Liberating Theory, and we continue here, as with prior chapters, with the associated dialogue. But in this episode, we are going to excerpt two chapters and their associated dialogues, so there will be more to come after this immediate dialogue. For those listeners who are familiar with the work of the seven authors of Liberating Theory, myself, Leslie Kagan, Noam Chomsky, Robin Hinnell, Mel King, Lydia Sargent, and Holly Sklar, it may prove interesting to consider how they all managed to write and edit the various parts of their joint book into existence. Each author had primary areas of personal focus and yet also an overarching holistic orientation. This would cause me to predict, looking back, but not remembering, that one or another author would have had more or less to say about different parts of the whole, just as might be the case for different people encountering the whole now in 2026. At any rate, here is the dialogue that was prepared back then for the polity anarchism chapter.
Roundtable Arguments Over Power
SPEAKER_00Coho, our complementary holistic, that is liberating theory participant, got things rolling. Depending on the character of the political sphere, people will be hierarchically arrayed accordingly. Whatever form the state takes, political relations influence not only the distribution of governmental decision making power, but the consciousness which people bring to their economic, kinship, and community spheres. And political relations greatly affect the ways social institutions mediate and disseminate information and misinformation. Moreland, our Marxist-Leninist participant, a little daunted from the economy conversation, but still eager to begin as usual, replies The absence of any economic analysis renders anarchist concepts practically useless. In addition, they are so obsessed with hierarchies that many anarchists oppose all forms of organization, including democratic states, unions, and political parties. Sophie, our socialist feminist participant, friendly but concerned, reacts. I have to agree with Morland's criticism of your lack of economic analysis, Anna, but also I find that anarchism does not provide a way of understanding how state structures vary according to part patriarchal influences. And while most anarchists oppose hierarchical relations between men and women, adults and children, they don't understand the bases of these hierarchies as they stem from kinship relations or why these hierarchies persist. Rad Femm, our radical feminist participant, friendly but also concerned, adds, I too have found much to admire in the often passionate and eloquent writings and actions of anarchists against authoritarianism. But I have to admit, Anna, that while individual anarchists personally oppose homophobia and sexual repression, their opposition seems to be based more on opposition to state intervention than a real understanding of the issues involved, or a commitment to a non heterosexually dominated society. Nate, our analyst participant, dubious but also friendly, adds I find your concern for minority rights and concerns even less impressive than Morlin's, Sophie's, and Red Femmes. Your analysis doesn't look at the complexity of racial oppression or how state structures vary dependent on splits in community spheres. Koho continues, that's certainly true. Like Marxists, anarchists tend to see only the ways that community forms support the oppression they want to eliminate, not how they meet human needs. Anna, our anarchist persist participant, responds in a friendly fashion. We anarchists are often free and open to new concepts, so I have no trouble, unlike some of you, admitting that I'm starting to like Koho's approach approach quite a bit, particularly its criticism of Marxism. Pluri, our pluralist participant, adds something's wrong here. This is all too friendly. Anna, but Plury, I spoke too soon. Anna, let me remind each of you, in the spirit of comradeship, mind you, of a few things. First, Marlin, you don't criticize state power or workplace hierarchies. Is that because you believe in them? Have you carved a place for yourself at the top of one of them? And Sophie, while I appreciate your supportive comments and the application of anarchist tenets by the women's movement, I have also found that many women's organizations and individual feminists stop criticizing others' power once they have gained a little themselves. Nor have I seen incredible efforts by the women's movement to criticize state power. I have seen more efforts to have equal access to that power. And Rad Fem, your theory simply posits a new authority, that of women over men, homosexuality over heterosexuality. And Nate, while the civil rights movement was infused with the spirit, if not the practice of democracy, the black power movements were the most hierarchical I've seen. Or is this a white construct? And Neopop, well, you get the idea. Each one of your spheres has not dealt adequately with questions of power. Coho, well put, I agree. But I think anarchists themselves could be criticized for the very same things. I don't think that anarchists suffer only from overemphasizing political hierarchies as the cause of all others, or for failing to recognize kinship, community, and economic spheres. Anarchists also fail to adequately describe the state itself. You identify intrinsic power dynamics, but you don't then go on to understand the intricacies of bureaucracy or the means of information and communication control tied in with various types of state relations. In short, your analysis is too simplified. Anna, friendly to the end, reacts. So the theory is often better than the practice. I am already willing to broaden my framework. But at the risk of seeming monist, Koho, how can we weave all these spheres together into one holistic cloth that avoids new forms of dominance and subsumption? Sin, our cynical participant, leaning forward in the chair in the corner. I can answer that. You can't Anna, with a supreme effort at friendliness, replies We appreciate your constructive comments. Sin Coho interrupts Rustling papers over the hostile mutterings destroying the friendly atmosphere. Now to continue on to society. I interject. Liberating Theory continues with Ch chapter six, excerpted here.
Monism Pluralism And Holism
SPEAKER_00It begins in chapters two to five, we have shown how four spheres of social life help form the basis for important facets of daily life. To use the concepts presented in those chapters to now formulate a monus theory, we would next have to demonstrate that one of the four spheres is more dominant than the others. For example, we might argue, like cultural nationalists, that community must exert a disproportionate influence over the forces of social stability and change because everything depends on how we culturally relate to things. Or instead, like anarchists, we might emphasize politics on the basis that the state dominates all decision making and power hierarchies clarify all oppressions. But while to be monist we would have to highlight one sphere, as these orientations do, we could nonetheless propose any of many possible forms of asymmetry between our favored sphere and others. For example, we might argue for economic priority, but urge that the economic sphere is only quote determinant in the last instance, end quote, rather than always dominant. Or we could recognize the quote relative autonomy of the state versus highlighted cultural differences, and so on. Alternatively, to formulate our same concepts into a pluralist theory, we would need to analyze each sphere separately using its own concepts and then sum the results, much as many Marxist feminists do for the economy and kinship. Our key assumption would then be that the most basic defining features in each sphere are not significantly contoured by dynamics from outside that sphere. But in contrast to monist and pluralist approaches, if we choose a complementary wholest approach, we must anticipate the possibility of more complex interconnections between spheres, even as we deny that these will always necessarily form a fixed hierarchy of influences. This approach, like socialist feminism for only two spheres, denies both the logic of elevating one sphere above others and the logic of trying to simply sum separate abstract analyses into a whole. Holism asserts that any hierarchy of influence of spheres in a particular society is something that must be empirically demonstrated in particular historical situations. It doubts that all societies even have hierarchies of influences, and it denies that the existence of a fixed hierarchy in one society demonstrates or implies the existence of the same hierarchy in another. Indeed, holism leads us to anticipate that with more exacting theories of particular societies we will often find that all four spheres operate centrally, and this claim is based not on logical or historical necessity, but on our knowledge of conceptual possibilities and our empirical awareness. I interject. That may sound a bit complicated. If you give it a little time and you think about it, I don't think it really is. The liberating theory presentation might not be as ideal and as clear as it would be desirable, but the actual claims are pretty straightforward. I hope that will become more evident as we proceed.
Social Moments And Interacting Spheres
SPEAKER_00The chapter continues Holism is also distinguishable from pluralism by its insistence on employing concepts from other spheres when analyzing dynamics within any particular sphere. The summing we advocate recognizes a greater degree of connectivity between social factors and highlights the degree to which one sphere's determining influences help define characteristics of another sphere, so that spheres do not really exist independently, separately, but always in the context of a whole that defines them all. Treating spheres as quote networks and quote processes that extend throughout the space of societies and the time of history is one technique for recognizing this connectivity. In preceding chapters we discussed community, kinship, economic and political dynamics as if each operated more or less in isolation. At the same time, we have emphasized that all human activity affects all four of these aspects of human existence. For example, we call our activity in a factory economic whenever the transformation of material objects is its most important aspect for the purpose at hand. But this economic activity also has kinship, community, and political quote moments, we might call it. Moreover, any activity that combines material, social, and human ingredients to create material, social and human products with new attributes is economic. But doesn't this imply that every activity has a quote economic moment? When we clean house, play, go to school, watch TV, or attend a concert or sporting event, don't we consume and produce material, human and social factors? And vice versa. Don't work activities also socialize, create culture, and affect political options? This recognition of the multidimensionality and essential unity of diverse activities extends to the level of the different spheres of society as well. For example, the economic sphere includes all institutions which involve production, consumption, and allocation of material objects as part of their social relations. By this definition, factories, marketplaces, and banks are obviously economic institutions. But elementary schools, which we usually think of as kinship institutions because of their socialization function, also involve production and consumption of material objects, as do theaters, households, senates, churches, and ballparks. In fact, if we extend the economic sphere to its fullest dimension, we discover that it encompasses all of society, and that every institution resides within the economic institutional network. Indeed, it is this reality which makes effective theories of the economy powerful tools for understanding at least some things about all sides of social life. But the same reasoning applies to the community kinship and governing spheres. Every institution has a socialization aspect, cultural aspect, and decision making aspect, as well as an economic aspect. Families historically have acted as the central kinship institution. But socialization takes place in factories, offices, and marketplaces as well. The state is the principal focus of political activity, but it also produces and consumes material objects and reproduces and transforms cultural attitudes and relations. And as with economics, the fact that the extension of the kinship, community, and political spheres of life encompass all of society is what makes compelling theories of each of these spheres powerful tools for understanding at least certain things about all social relationships. The four spheres share the same space and time, even though they have different central institutions and focus on different social functions. It is as if the societies have four centers from which four different force fields emerge, mingle, and finally merge. Each of the four force fields not only affects like options and activities throughout society, they also affect one another, a complication that makes it difficult to comprehend the full character even of society's individual spheres. If we only study the characteristics of each field in isolation, we not only have no guide as to how to combine the results, we also misspecify the dynamics within each field because we do not see how they are influenced by forces emerging from the other three. We have said that we can think of any social act in terms of four quote moments related to the four defining types of social interaction. It is a little like the way we learned how to graphically track projectiles in high school. If we imagine a ball flying through the air, we can track its path by noting at each instant how high it is, how far it has gone along our line of sight, and how far it has gone perpendicular to the line of sight. We studied the forces pushing or impeding it in each of these three directions. If we want to study the ball being thrown across the field, we should choose a vertical axis in line with gravity and two horizontal axes measuring off the field in a grid along the line the wind is blowing and or the direction we will throw the ball. If we're tracking an airplane, we'll use longitude, latitude, and altitude. If we're tracking a spaceship, we may choose more complex, what are called curvilinear coordinates, because in this instance they will be easiest to use. But what if we want to track quote social trajectories? We have proposed conceptualizing society by carving it into components of four types of social relations. Yet unlike spatial directions, these social dimensions are not linear and they do not operate independently of one another. Influences relating to each have effects on the other three. In the throwing example, gravity acting along up down direction doesn't significantly change the wind effect along the horizontal direction, nor does our energy of throwing across the field affect gravity's influence perpendicular to it. But in societies, changes in quote forces acting primarily along the kinship dimension influence not only gender, but also economic community and political phenomena. In societies, everything is mutually interactive, and this severely complicates matters. Yet despite this critical complication, we choose our quote social dimensions for the same reason a physicist chooses a particular spatial conceptualization or any analyst chooses a particular way of organizing his or her concepts to provide the most effective framework for understanding chosen subject matter in ways relevant to particular ends being sought. In choosing four social spheres, we seek enough axes to span all the social dynamics we are interested in. But at the same time, we do not want any more axes than necessary. Moreover, for utility, we want our social axes to provide maximum ease of use to activist analysts. But what precisely do we mean by a quote social moment? Every social interaction, whether assembling cars or struggling for rent control, has aspects that can be most effectively understood through each of the four spheres we have discussed. We call these its economic, kinship, community, and political moments of definition. In real life, of course, these characteristics intertwine, so the four social moments do not manifest themselves separately any more than a ball simultaneously moves along all the infinity of spatial axes we can conceptualize. Yet gravity and wind do operate along specific spatial axes, and so too do specific forces within society operate along specific social dimensions. If we choose our social dimensions as those via which the most important forces most often operate, specific social moments will help us easily perceive the action of critically important forces and their interconnections. I interject again. Listeners may be feeling that discussion has a what is currently called an intersectional feel to it. And so it does, but liberating theory was prior to that stance emerging, and also, I believe, different in some important respects. The chapter continues What possible kinds of relations can exist between the four spheres and their fields of force? People aren't economically affected in one part of their lives and gender affected in another, state influenced one day of the week and community influenced some other day. Instead, they simultaneously experience economic, kinship, governance, and community involvements, and this guarantees that spheres interact. At a particular time, class may have more influence on molding a person's consciousness and behavior than gender, or vice versa, but these influences must coexist. Societies consist of diverse relations combined in complex ways. If the different relations become completely estranged, societies Itself would become impossible. Different parts of our lives would produce such profoundly contradictory thought and behavior patterns that we would become hopelessly disoriented. In stable societies there is a constant interplay of mechanisms to reconcile contradictory dynamics before they get out of hand. Profound schisms which cannot be reconciled characterize unstable societies ripe for social revolutions. Conservative functionalist social theories assume that in all societies sufficient mechanisms exist to reconcile all contradictory role requirements and socialize people to accept those roles without questioning the humanity of this fit. Radicals, on the other hand, tend to us underestimate the influence of stabilizing and ameliorating mechanisms. For example, with no interconnections, our kinship life might socialize us to become non acquisitive and anti competitive, while our economic life might require opposite traits, or our community life might produce mutual respect for different cultures, while our political institutions require instrumentalist, elitist authoritarian attitudes. If one part of society says we should have a particular quality, and another part says we should have the opposite quality, where the quality in question is one that will help define our personality and structure our life prospects, social instability arises. With no way to alleviate the resulting tensions, not only would social cohesion disintegrate as people clash with each other and with themselves, but each person's internal psychology would tend to disintegrate due to confused self definition. Society would be terminally schizoid. Something would have to give, but theory would not tell us in advance of analyzing specific circumstances what that something would be. Theory without investigation, that is, could not tell us that one of the tendencies would always dominate another. Nor could theory tell us to predict without seeking evidence whether the unstable situation would revert back to a form of stable status quo or move on to a new social formation not characterized by dynamics that produce both qualities and their opposites. But it is precisely our theoretical knowledge of the existence of diverse types of interactive dynamics between spheres and fields coupled with detailed surveys, detailed surveys of the conditions of actual societal relations that can together help us predict how instabilities are likely to resolve to recreate workable social orders of one kind or another. In workable social orders it follows that there will be intricate interconnections between defining spheres of social activity. In our effort to understand societies as they appear at a given moment, what remains is to ask what forms those expected interconnections can take. I interject. I mentioned earlier that it was seeming very, very complex. Now it may become a bit clearer as we look into the kinds of interactions.
Accommodation Versus Codefinition
SPEAKER_00The chapter continues one kind of interaction between spheres that is consistent with stability is accommodation. Critical features of each sphere may accommodate to requirements of other spheres. For example, the assignment of people to economic roles may accommodate with a society's sexist, gender, and racist community hierarchies, so the economic activity places men in positions above women and whites in positions above blacks, for example. Similarly, if there are accommodation relations between the kinship and political spheres, the family will socialize children in ways consistent with the state related roles they will play as adults and political activity will produce traits that comply with the family roles men and women are to play. In the journey from the simplest pluralism to complementary holism, recognizing accommodation between spheres is the first tentative step. But another more deeply connective type of relationship consistent with social stability is what we call codefinition. The different spheres codefine one another's internal roles and relations. For example, instead of economic roles being determined entirely by class divisions and bargaining relationships and individuals' assignments to various economic roles merely accommodating to non economic external hierarchies, the very definition of economic roles in the first place could reflect influences from kinship, political or community spheres. Work roles in the corporation might incorporate a sexual division of labor inexplicable in solely economic terms, yet easily understood as a manifestation of a sexist field of force. Nurturing roles in the family might vary depending upon community affiliations, thereby showing defining characteristics inexplicable in solely kinship terms, yet easily understood as a manifestation of a cultural field of force. It would not be enough to theorize the economy and then note via the principle of accommodation that since men and women are differentiated by kinship relations outside the economy, they will be treated differently within the economy as well. Instead, even in theorizing the most basic elements of the economy, we would have to determine the defining impact of kinship forces. And likewise for theorizing kinship and incorporating community recognitions. Recognizing this necessity is the critical step from even the most complex pluralism to complementary holism. It corresponds to the difference between those who pluralistically join orientations, like Marxist feminists, and those who holistically adopt a more encompassing framework, like socialist feminists, or taking all sword spheres into account complementary wholes. There is nothing inherent in capitalist economic relations that requires the activity of coffee making to be assigned to the role of secretary. There is no purely economic reason why in the US women are ghettoized into so-called quote pink collar jobs, clerical work, nursing, domestic work, restaurant and food service, retail sales, elementary school teaching, etc. There is nothing about economics that requires that in addition to different levels of compensation, women's and men's activities must or even should involve different degrees of oversight and mobility. Purely economic dynamics cannot explain such profound gender differentiations. In this sense, then, not only do economic relations accommodate kinship hierarchies by placing women in the lowest economically defined positions, but patriarchy code defines basic economic relations. In the very definition of economic roles, if only class factors can be at play, in which case low level but genderless jobs will, by accommodation, go to women and others at the bottom of non class hierarchies, or alternatively, codefining kinship forces can also operate so as to generate subordinate feminine gender defined jobs, such as being a secretary, whose responsibilities include maternal services such as coffee making, gift purchasing, and birthday reminding. Whenever gender dynamics codefine economic relations, not only will men and women be assigned to different economic roles, but those roles themselves will have characteristics in part determined by kinship dynamics. Similarly, whenever community forces codefine kinship relations, cultural differences will permeate gender roles, so families whose members belong to different communities will have different role structures. The roles of mother and father may differ significantly in Afro American, Chicano, and Anglo American families. The logic carries from sphere to sphere. When we look at societies via any monus theory, most dimensions of differences among people are reduced to peripheral concern. When we've switched to pluralism, we see each type of difference, but not how they contour one another. When we choose complementary holism, we have the potential to develop a comprehensive picture. Indeed, an especially critical consequence of codefinition that not that only a holist approach fully highlights is that quote class consciousness will vary depending on gender, political, and community allegiances. Women's consciousness will differ for women of different classes, political allegiances, and communities. Afro American, Latino, or Native American consciousness will differ depending on gender, political, and class allegiances, and political consciousness will vary depending upon gender, community, and class allegiances.
Core Characteristics Across Society
SPEAKER_00In short, complementary holism highlights all the critical kinds of possible interconnections in human societies. First society is viewed as a whole, a single system of people and institutions inextricably bound together. Only then and only for specific purposes do we abstract four different components or social spheres for separate analysis. But the characteristics of each sphere are viewed as multiply determined by one another, and the specific ways in which the spheres accommodate and co define one another are a primary subject of examination. Still, even this array of concepts leaves us feeling insufficiently prepared. It would be nice to focus specifically on general relations between people and what we often call quote the system. Within Marxism, the concepts base and superstructure play an important role. Since Marxists see the economy as more important than other spheres, it is only sensible for them to carve up society according to materialist economic hierarchy. Economic relations form the base. Everything else is more or less lumped together in a dependent superstructure. Different Marxists use this ordering in different ways, some allowing the superstructure to have more influence on the base and some less. For instance, the Maoist theory of the Cultural Revolution grants greater influence to superstructural phenomena. Feminists, nationalists, and anarchists could all also employ the base superstructure terminology, though the composition of the base would differ for each. In contrast, having located not only economic but also politics, community, and kinship in society's core, we do not want to impose a quote productivist or sphere centering hierarchy on our method. Similarly, after having argued that material, social, and ideological relations operate interactively in each type of activity and social sphere, again, we would be foolish to assert an always operative material or ideological dominance. So while no base superstructure hierarchy is compatible with a complementary holist approach, it does make sense for us to distinguish between the people in any society with all their individual and group traits or what we call the human center, and the social roles, institutions, and institutional relations in that society or what we call the institutional boundary. The allusion to architecture in these labels has a purpose. The institutional boundary of a society textures possibilities by imposing systemic or structural limits on people's behavior from without. Within any society, the boundary includes the intricate array of role offerings that constitute the society's many institutions. The roles quote surround us and restrict our choices. To gain whatever benefits society has to offer as workers, parents, voters, neighbors, etc., we must fit ourselves into these role structures or risk being ostracized socially and penalized economically and politically. The human center, on the other hand, embraces human feeling, need, thought, skill, consciousness, desire, creative expression, and personality. The ideas and acts of individuals and groups within the center radiate outward, in turn influencing the boundary and even transcending successive generations. The idea of one realm surrounding another is only a graphical approximation of the dynamic between the two realms. It is not a literal description. In fact, the center and boundary occupy the same time and space as one another, and are therefore really a single whole, just as the four spheres are. And again, like the four spheres, the center and boundary also intersect, overlap, accommodate, and codefine in a complementary way. But while the spheres distinguish between different kinds of activities, while lumping together the people and institutions that determine those activities, the concepts of social center and boundary distinguish between people and institutions while lumping together different kinds of activity. Indeed, each sphere has a center element and a boundary element, people and institutional roles. Moreover, society's center and boundary each have aspects of all four spheres. The conceptual carvings are simply two compatible overwhelming overlapping ways of looking at things. The introduction of this new set of concepts is not a matter of quote different strokes for different folks, but different conceptual tools for different analytical tasks. And the next addition to our toolkit for the task of focusing on critical defining aspects of social life is the concept core characteristics. We define a quote core characteristic as a defining feature of a society which centrally influences life options by significantly affecting the character of both the human center and the institutional boundary. Core characteristics usually begin as defining characteristics of the activity of a particular social sphere, and then through accommodation and codefinition come to affect the quality of life throughout the rest of society as well. For example, in quote class societies, class relations certainly help define all economic role structures and texture all economic possibilities. Yet in addition, beyond the economy, class hierarchies usually impose themselves on the character of governing kinship and community relations as well. Indeed, it is because class frequently permeates all social definitions and textures, all aspects of lived experience that the Marxist label class society truly does have meaning beyond the economic sphere. In such situations, a specific class structure will become a core characteristic affecting all of social life. In the United States, for example, capitalist exploitation is a core characteristic. But in the United States, the same holds true for sexism flowing from the kinship sphere, racism flowing from the community sphere, and a particular type of authoritarianism flowing from the political sphere. In other words, not only is capitalist exploitation a core characteristic of U.S. society, but so are racism, sexism, and authoritarianism. While we believe this to be true for the United States, we are not arguing that in all societies at all times each sphere of social activity must generate a feature that becomes a core characteristic. Whether or not this occurs depends on the nature of the social activity in different social spheres and the nature of the interconnections between those spheres in each particular society. The important point is that multiple core characteristics are a possibility deserving serious investigation.
Human Center And Institutional Boundary
SPEAKER_00Unfortunately, this is rarely contemplated even as a possibility by most theoreticians. At this point, we want to address a question that is likely disturbing at least a few of our readers. We know society can be conceptualized in many different ways. We agree that the task is to formulate those conceptualizations that will most effectively meet our needs as students and agents of social change. But why choose exactly four spheres for our conceptual framework? Carving societies into our four chosen spheres is only one of countless possible options. We cannot possibly maintain it provides the only effective, right or revealing way to do things. Our argument in favor of choosing these four particular spheres to ground our theory of social stability and social change rests on the validity of the following claims. One, each activity necessarily exists in any society. Two, each activity is carried out through elaborate social relationships that define a significant portion of people's life prospects. Three, none of the four types of activity reduces to or is subsumed by any of the others. Four, all of the activities and spheres influence one another and all social outcomes. So five, if our priority is understanding society in order to change it, not highlighting any of these spheres would cause us to run a grave risk of incompletely theorizing our circumstances. And six, if we seek the most manageable framework for developing analyses, vision, and strategy, adding additional spheres would simply complicate matters and no great gain in facilitating understanding. Of course, we cannot deny the possibility that some other type of activity will meet the first four criteria, so that points five and six will apply only to an expanded set of five or more spheres, but so far we have not found this to be the case. I interject you'll see shortly, I think, I honestly don't remember this chapter, but I think that there is an addition to be made. If not, we'll see it later. The chapter continues. Economic, political, kinship, and community relations will always exist, though their influence in different societies may vary greatly. Whatever wherever movements seek to overcome forms of domin of domination, we can safely bet that conceptualizing along these particular social dimensions will significantly inform their efforts. To be sure, in different times and societies, different spheres may have greater or lesser influence in defining oppressions and eliciting social movements. But the lack of conscious social movement along a particular axis does not diminish the theoretical usefulness of that axis. Instead, the lack of social movement itself requires explanation, using the theoretical tools pertaining to that particular sphere and to others as well. To quote abstract means to pull apart out from the whole for separate analysis. When we discuss a society's economy without paying attention to its culture, for example, we abstract out the economy from the whole. Sometimes abstractions lead to the definition of concepts and angles of focus that provide exceptional insights, not only pedagogically by making our thoughts simpler because unessential complex complexities have been left out, but also practically by yielding results which seem fully applicable in real societies and which would not have been seen but for making the abstraction in the first place. Other times, however, we will separately conceptualize and analyze some part of the whole at greater length and Only to find that in real world interactions, few of our abstract results may remain valid. The real world is characterized by interconnectedness. Everything exists in one whole, defined by and defining everything else. Yet within the whole, we can distinguish parts which exhibit modeled abstract dynamics which differ little from their real dynamics in complex environment. Their interconnectedness or connectivity with other relations doesn't intrude on the features we focus on when we fo when we consider them abstractly, isolated from interactions, at least to the degree of description we are pursuing. The effects of quantum dynamics within falling apples on their gravitational attraction to the Earth are so minute that if we are only concerned about the apples' rate of fall, we can ignore them. In contrast, Marxist feminist, nationalist, and anarchist theories, which are generally developed by abstracting economic, gender, community, and state relations from all others, end up suggesting effects which are so modified by the process of abstracting that when we take into account factors ignored in the abstract analyses, we see that those analyses are no longer reliable guides to real relations. I interject, that doesn't mean those analyses say nothing of value. It just means that the degree to which they have abstracted have made some of the things that they say not helpful or perhaps even counterproductive. The chapter continues. The point of our complementary wholest framework is to provide an overarching conceptual carving that can simultaneously give us an encompassing view and also refine each particular angle of conceptualization so it does not suffer from being too abstracted from all other angles of conceptualization. So regarding the possible demarcation of a fifth sphere, at a conceptual level, we must ask whether it clarifies or obscures our analytical vision. Radical activists must ask whether adding an additional sphere highlighting another dimension currently subsumed in one or more of our four would allow us to more easily see important relations for issues of social change and strategy that might otherwise have been overlooked or misunderstood. If yes, then as activists we should take this extra conceptual step. If not, it would complicate matters unnecessarily. For example, the kinship sphere is the primary site of what we have termed kinship sexual child rearing activity, and the principal source of visions along gender lines. We have argued that division by sexual preference forms an integral part of the dynamic of kinship activity, and that just as sexism emerges from the dynamics of kinship, so does heterosexism and homophobia. Seeing things this way, we would discuss questions of sexuality and sexual preference as one complex part of the whole arrangement of phenomena associated with kinship. This is not, however, the only approach we could take. Instead of four defining spheres, we might choose to demarcate five. We can argue, for example, that sexuality itself is the locus of a sphere of human activity, which can project defining social characteristics as autonomously as any other defining activity can. We could argue further that a basic oppressive dynamic associated with this additional sphere of social life is quote erodophobia, the fear and hatred of sexuality, whose primary manifestation is homophobia. The choice between these alternative frameworks depends largely on an assessment of the value of the alternative ways of conceptualizing in light of our goal of promoting social change. In a homophobic, erodophobic society, will a fourfold division that subsumes complex issues of sexuality within a sphere primarily concerned with gender produce an understanding of sexuality sufficient to our needs? Or alternatively, just as we find it necessary to break out politics from economics, for example, must we break out sexuality from kinship, disentangling sexuality to permit a closer, potentially more insightful reading of society. It seems evident that like economic, political, cultural, and gender activity, sexual activity has historical universality. Moreover, sexual activity often has the effect of demarcating important social divisions. But this isn't enough since one could say the same thing about subparts of the economic sphere, arguing the need to separate production from consumption and allocation, but be rebutted because this step is unwarranted due to the fact that production, consumption, and allocation are just different phases of one process that produces a seamless web of effects. Does the same hold for sexuality as an element of kinship relations? Or with sexuality as opposed to matters of gender definition and child rearing, do we need to employ two conceptual structures and locuses of focus to achieve full understanding? Following a similar tack, an argument could be made for dividing race and religion off from ethnicity, or even for including entirely new spheres of different sorts having to do, for example, with cognition and psychology. What is to prevent this? Are there times when it would be important to undertake such steps? In chapter one, we suggested a utilitarian norm for governing how we define concepts. The issue is not a matter of quote abstract theoretical power, but one of quote use value in finding truths that we need to understand for our particular purposes. The point of presenting of our presenting provocative examples for possible fifth spheres has been to show that the conceptualizations elaborated in this book in no sense constitute a closed and inviable system. But for now, we think we can manage with four main conceptual angles. Not because we think issues such as sexuality are relatively unimportant, but because we think that like many other important dynamics, they can be effectively handled within a fourfold orientation. Whether this choice is optimal will depend on how powerful our emerging theory proves to be as we proceed to discussions of whole societies and history, vision and strategy.
Should Sexuality Be A Sphere
SPEAKER_00A holistic analysis of society's school system, to take one example, would look at not only how the schools socialize children to become adults, but also how the schools pass on cultural awareness, teach necessary economic skills, and carry out political functions. A holistic analysis would identify the aspects of the socialization process in schools that reproduce societies defining kinship norms, say sexism and heterosexism, but would also identify ways in which school activities were incompatible with established kinship norms, equal budgets for male and female athletic programs, or boys taking home economics classes and girls taking shop. A holistic analysis would also look for reproductive and destabilizing effects of schools on racial, religious, class, and political relations? Are children segregated and tracked by race? Or is integration through busing or other means challenging racist norms? Are children being tracked in ways that teach conceptual skills to a few future coordinators and wrote vocational skills to many? Or are more children of working class parents receiving pre-college and college education than will be able to find thinking jobs in the economy? Are children getting a sanitized, anglicized version of American history? Or are they taking social studies courses that study the genocidal treatment of Native Americans and approach the Vietnam War from a critical perspective?
Ecology And The World System
SPEAKER_00But as powerful as this orientation may be, the complementary holist approach as described so far is still incomplete. Not only have we left the fundamental issues of social stability and change to the next chapter dealing with history, but in addition, we have left out all reference to the ecology and paid little attention to a world system of many societies. The natural ecology includes the flora, fauna, resources, and general habitat of the non human created environment. It operates as an immensely complicated system in which intricate interconnections between the life cycles of different species, the climate and the physical environment determine overarching characteristics. A society includes the human created network of social relations we have spent this chapter conceptualizing. A social ecology, however, is the combination of natural of a natural ecology and a society, which once again form a single complementary whole. We can view the natural ecology and society in much the same way we have viewed different spheres within a particular society. Each shapes and is shaped by the other. Looked at from one perspective, they weave a single seamless whole. Looked at from another perspective, they act as two different systems, accommodating or code defining one another. Each perspective is useful for particular purposes, and together they comprise the complementary wholest view that we have developed throughout this book. For some purposes we can therefore usually usefully treat a society as a separate system. For other purposes we do so at risk. For example, as the ecologists have tried to teach us, if we wish to create a world in which we can live safely for longer than another half century, we can leave out ecological considerations only at our own peril. I interject only for another half century. The book was written forty years ago. The chapter continues. Murray Bookchin conveys this lesson, for example, when he urges that we should not allow ourselves to succumb to a heavy handed dualism that separates the natural from the social, or to fall into a reductionism that dissolves the one into the other, since committing either of these errors cripples our ability to think out the real issues involved. Similarly, we feel that an ecological perspective needs to become part of our guiding philosophy of life. In this book we have so far included chapters on four spheres of social life, and in this chapter we have argued for a conceptual approach to analg to amalgamating the four sets of critical concepts into a holistic view of society. In addition, however, a fully complementary holist view of social ecology sufficient to the needs of activists concerned with creating a better world also requires ecological concepts that can operate on their own and be integrated into the overall approach as well. Yet not all ecological perspectives are equally likely to contribute to improving social or even ecological relations. For example, traditional Western mainstream ecologists apply instrumentalist approaches common in modern hierarchical societies to the problem of manipulating and taming nature. These technocratic ecologists treat nature as another tool particular human elites can manipulate for their own ends. This view calls itself ecological, but it has nothing in common with the complementary holist approach we have celebrated. Instead, this attitude toward nature co-reproduces tendencies that emerge from contemporary social forms characterized by domination and exploitation. We need to incorporate an ecological perspective that will co-reproduce a liberatory worldview. We are confident complementary wholest methodology will complement an ecologically sound attitude to the natural ecology. With Booksham, we believe that this approach can sensitize us to the intricate connection between human and non human relationships, quote, neither mechanically reducing them to a false, undifferentiated oneness, nor totally breaking the bonds between them to wrongly imply they are unconnected. End quote. We have no doubt many ecological concepts will be needed in addition to the social concepts presented in this volume. And though we cannot discuss specific ecological concepts here, we believe they can be integrated effectively into a whole framework. Every society interacts not only with nature, but also with other societies. Throughout history, varying forms of imperialism, national chauvinism, and strategic alliances have existed as critical factors, shaping not only the history of the world, but the development of individual societies as well. Colonialism has dramatically shaped the societies of the colonial powers as well as the colonies, with the latter, of course, suffering far more damaging consequences. Countries with highly valued resources, such as oil, have seen their national incomes rise to dwarf countries with no such resources. Almost all societies divert enormous resources to military establishment in the face of real or exaggerated external threats. Countries perceived to have pivotal roles in geostrategic superpower competition are subject to far more consistent external pressure than less important countries. Intervention clearly constrains and threatens liberatory developments in countries such as Nicaragua or El Salvador. We should never forget that intervention to destroy progressive movements and governments is the rule, not the exception, and that historically most of these interventions have succeeded. Where revolutions have survived, they have been distorted. Imagine how different national and world history would be only over the last three decades if the people of Guatemala and the Dominican Republic, and Brazil and Chile, and Jamaica and Granada, and Cuba and Nicaragua, and El Salvador and Vietnam and Cambodia and South Korea and Ireland and Hungary and Czechoslovakia and Iran and Angola and Mozambique and Zimbabwe were able to have made and keep making their own history without intervention by the United States or the Soviet Union. We have not attempted to offer a detailed treatment of international dynamics, but we feel the holist approach is well suited to doing so. Imperialism is one of the subjects most conducive to a holist analysis, since imperialism so clearly manifests all four elements of causation. In our opinion, much that has been lacking in various theories of international relations stems from ignoring one or more moments. For example, the influence of patriarchy has been almost universally overlooked until recently. Or from assuming that one or another moment must always be dominant. Marxist-Leninist theories of imperialism, defined solely as the monopoly stage of capitalism, an economic system, are a prime example of the latter point. Applying a holist approach to relations between countries should give us a better understanding of the impact of community dynamics of race and religion, for instance, in the U.S. occupation of Grenada or British occupied Northern Ireland or the Israeli occupied West Bank. It would help us understand the exploit of w exploitation of women by multinational corporations or military institutions, for instance the use of rape in warfare and the cultivation of prostitution around U.S. military bases, and the role these play these play both in structuring the form of international relations and their motivations. Likewise, this approach should help explicate the meaning of cultural imperialism, for example, the westernization, Americanization of consumption and definitions of beauty, and the role this plays. If it turns out we need additional concepts especially suited to the macro context of intersociety connections to get an analysis comprehensive enough for our activist needs, as we likely need additional ecological concepts, for example, this should not be a problem for the whole framework. If these additions cause us to have to return to our society level concepts to adapt their basic definitions in light of the defining impact of world level quote fields of force, a degree of alteration we do not expect to have to undertake, that too would be a workable step for our methodology, though it might lead to significant alterations to the results obtained so far in this volume. So ended chapter six proper. And below we include its associated dialogue.
Why Complexity Aims To Simplify
SPEAKER_00But first, I interject from my viewing point, vantage from my vantage point in twenty twenty six. As I read this material to convey it in this episode, I have had many thoughts and would like to convey two. First, liberating theory was a kind of holistic project itself. None of the authors alone would have come up with the chapters, neither their substance or their style. This really was, I can tell not only from vague memories of doing it with the others, but from knowing each participant's own work and seeing how the whole differs from and is even greater than the sum of its parts. Second, I can imagine some people reading or hearing this material and feeling like geez, it is way too much. It is too complicated. I can also imagine others feeling like wonderful. There are so many angles and pieces we can now dig into it at our desk, going this way and that way endlessly. I would like to suggest both these reactions would miss the point. Yes, complementary holism has lots of focuses and ideas, concepts that are added to activists' proposed toolboxes. And here they are presented very succinctly in a very small space. But give it a little time. The additions aren't obscure. They d they aren't so vague that you can imprint anything you want on them. And their point isn't to complexify, but instead to simplify. Not the list of concepts, but the task of using them. They mean to propose manageable methods and concepts so to activists and concepts to activists to use in addressing real circumstances, complexly enough to capture what we need, but not more. They meant to be fixed flexible, they meant to be flexible enough to alter, yet with a little effort, clear and complete enough to provide unifying awareness. That wasn't the outcome forty years ago. There was no unifying awareness that spread through the left as a result of the book Liberating Theory. As I read this chapter to you now, and I bet for the next two as well, I honestly wonder why it wasn't. What was wrong or missing, or poorly conveyed, or flawed for whatever reason? Hopefully, if there are such problems, they will now get addressed, and if instead the obstacles to a new liberating theory were instead somehow contingently in us back then, they too will be overcome. That at least was and is my reason for offering this material again in this sequence of episodes and associated articles. I interject. But now returning to the material, here is the dialogue.
Testing Holism Against Soviet Reality
SPEAKER_00It starts with Koho warming to her task and a summing up of the strengths of complementary holism as a method for better understanding societies, who says and so holism emphasizes that all human activity affects all four spheres of human existence. Once more, it asserts that any hierarchy of influence in a particular society must be empirically demonstrated. Holism recognizes the connectivity of spheres so that spheres Who exist in the context of a whole that defines them all, Morlin interrupts with renewed vigor. It still seems suicidal to me to throw out an already existing powerful materialist theory. Your complimentary holist approach is all concepts and no theory. Why not build carefully from an economic theory that is universal? Nate, not giving up. Still at it, Morlin? Why not take the community sphere and build off that? Rad Fem, also not giving up. The kinship sphere Anna reminding them. The political sphere. Koho. But it's true that we still need to apply complementary wholest concepts to generate specific theories of particular societies. Marlin, challenging. What does your framework hope you to understand about the Soviet Union, for instance, that I would ignore? Koho. You look at the Soviet Union and see a deformed socialist society. The economy to you has socialist forms. The state is a bureaucracy. You proceed to blame these details on poverty, capitalist encirclement, Stalinism, problems located within the state, prior history or other countries. You analyze in detail the intricate problems of the Soviet planning system, bemoaning its centralization and subordination to the party. But you never see the forest for the trees. The Soviet Union has neither a capitalist nor a socialist mode of production. CC, our Council Communist, chimes in. And as I understand it, Coho, your complementary holist approach, correct me if I'm wrong, would give a completely different view. You would describe the coordinator economic sphere in which planners, managers, and other conceptual workers occupy positions of ruling economic status. And you would see a bureaucratic dictatorial state, which still in part administers the economy because in the early days there weren't enough coordinators to do the job. And because worker self-management was anathema to Leninists. Nate. And have I got this right, Koho? Wouldn't your approach allow us to see complex community sphere in the Soviet Union, in which minority cultural communities struggle for dignity against forces that seek to reduce cultural variety to dominant Russian norms. Assimilation with respect, you might call it, or more aptly cultural homogenization. Marlin, you are so obsessed with maintaining your heritage, Nate, that you fail to appreciate the struggle to create a new socialist culture. Nate, new cultural forms that trample spiritual life and whose aesthetics emphasize socialist realism. This is not a culture I would fight to create. Sophie, and add to this, Koho, I if I leave something out, wouldn't your approach see a patriarchal kinship sphere in the Soviet Union in which women suffer domination at the hands of sexist men? And while institutional structures differ from those in the US, they are patriarchal nonetheless. Rad Fem and if I've understood Koho correctly, the entire question of sexuality, sexual preference, subtle and not so subtle gender divisions throughout society would only be peripherally considered by a Marxist analysis. Marlin, holding fast, I am not convinced that an expanded monist approach isn't the most useful for our purposes. Anna, but if I may explain what Koho's getting at here, an enlightened monism in the hands of a clever Marxist simply expands a narrow economic focus. Factory work as first cause gives way to production in general, which becomes all economic activity, which gives way to a concept that emphasizes not only production and consumption, but reproduction in the factory and the family, which grows to encompass production and reproduction of ideas, people, and culture. CC. Even the definition of class, am I right, Coho, expands to encompass features rooted in sexual, political, and cultural divisions of labor. But it is all based on economic material features, Sophie. And so it is too narrow. For example, when economic concepts are extended to incorporate kinship relations, they only address kinship attributes insofar as they are analogous to production and consumption. Rad Fem to see income differentials more than sexual norms of teenagers, job structures more than courtship practices and marriage vows, divisions of labor in the home rather than violence against women. No expansion of economy based concepts will enlighten anyone about erotiphia. Nate, what's more, even the most enlightened monist theories scare off activists. I must admit, white workers don't coalesce around black nationalist ideology, and certainly black nationalists won't support class demands that appear to apply to whites only. Pleury, but you've very nearly argued for my pluralist approach. All these oppressions exist and it's simply a question of picking the right tool for the job. Sophie, if I may, Coho. The difference between pluralism and Koho's approach is that the latter stresses the fact that we all simultaneously identify as members of classes, genders, communities, and political hierarchies. And this holistic experience of society determines how we each relate to our surroundings and what we expect from life. Anna, for instance, Radfem asks questions about gender and sexuality. Marlon asks questions about forces and relations of production and class struggle. Nate asks questions about culture and spirituality. I ask about politics and hierarchies. But Koho proposes an approach that makes it easier to ask more encompassing questions and to see important relationships, not just using one sphere here, one sphere there. Plury, I still don't see the difference. I think Koho's just obscuring the initi the issue unnecessarily. Koho Take the Soviet example again. The complementary holist approach helps us look at struggles within the Soviet coordinator class over the relative importance of market and planning forms, between workers and coordinators over management prerogatives, between coordinators and political bureaucrats over cultural definitions and rights, and among genders over divisions and role structures from the earliest days of the Soviet Union. CC. Yes, I think we're all beginning to see the possibilities. Coho. But what you're not seeing, I think, is Plury. I knew there'd be something. Coho, those involved in each particular sphere must be able to understand not only the concerns and dynamics of other spheres, but the interactive effects of trends within spheres on other spheres. Plury, this is so confusing. Coho. And to see the implications of these interactions on visions and strategies for change. To see the impossibility of building a liberatory theory, strategy and vision when separate conceptualizations and their movements are out of sync, when their relationship is not complementary but antagonistic. Rad Fem, you know, Coho, the more you argue with us, the more you attack Marlin in particular, the more I begin to see the same dynamics that made me opt for movement separatism. It all begins to sound so holier than thou. Koho, perhaps I do get a little carried away. Sophie, I must admit that I cringe every time your scientific analogies become almost a basis for quote proving the correctness of your concepts. Koho, I do get excited over my charts and spheres, but I don't mean my analogies as proofs. C C After all, Koho, what prevents the very inclusiveness and flexibility of your system from becoming as dogmatic as you describe ours to be, particularly Marlin's. Koho, I was just trying to pluri. And as I said earlier, what keeps your system from being so abstract, so intellectual that only you and a few others can constructively apply it? Neopop, on the contrary, I think the weakness of Koho's system is that she says too little about what who would administer it, who would take leadership. Nate, it is true that while I find myself developing a real affinity for Koho's approach and its potential, I still can't picture myself involved in organizing for voter registration by talking about quote social moments. Anna there se Anna, there seems to be something wrong with creating a tight intellectual system and calling it a theory of society and history. It still requires the arguing for an imposition of one system over another. Our interpersonal dynamics are centered around one person trouncing another, bludgeoning another, Rad Fem. Instead of being more Marxist than now, more feminist than now, more theoretical than now, Marlin, we can be more cohoist than thou. Coho are you arguing that there is no difference between a system which argues for the exclusion of others, as each of yours does, and a system which argues for the inclusion of others, as complementary wholism does? Between a system which argues for the elitist power of its adherents and a system that argues against elitism. Certainly there is something grandiose about trying to enunciate a theory of history when we know so little. It's time to organize around a theory that recognizes its limitations, that attempts to generate a democratic movement around shared ways of thinking about the world and a better future. Pluri sounds like a step forward from sectarian isolation, organizing around stars and leaders with temporary slogans and fears, with no shared coherent intellectual framework. Coho exactly. Regardless of the dangers, we have to embrace a theory and vision. We'd better make sure that the concepts we choose are useful, creative, and antisectarian as possible. A pause, then a familiar voice from the corner. Sin, our cynical participant. No one wants more that more than I. Historically, it's never been done. Coho over the ensuing groans. Since you mention it, sin, let's take a look at what history shows. Gloom begins to settle as they eye Koho happily wrestling through her papers.
Closing And Next Topic Preview
SPEAKER_00And all that said, this is Michael Albert, signing off until next time for Revolution Z. When we will take up, Dare I Suggest It, Concepts for Understanding History.