RevolutionZ
RevolutionZ
Ep 405 Liberating Theory Kinship Begets Gender...
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Episode 405 of RevolutionZ moves from Community and race last episode to Kinship, patriarchal sex gender relations, and feminism this episode. We start by noting, however, that after our What Is To Be Undone episodes that criticized long-standing left orthodoxies we got nearly no pushback at all--and none publicly--and wondering why that was while also hoping that soon reactions will appear.
Then this episode turns to ideas for a modified approach to gender, feminism, and the kinship sphere that greatly impacted revolutionary debate forty years ago and needs to do so now too. The material is excerpted from a book, Liberating Theory, that was co-authored by seven prominent activists and published in 1986. We authors tried to put forth positive proposals to later adapt and refine to arrive at a conceptual toolbox able to guide activism more successfully than the ideologies we employed in earlier periods. Liberating Theory hoped to aid creation of a New New Left. Its third chapter, presented here, summarized how kinship institutions organize the human life cycle, define roles like mother, father, husband, wife, and child, and then attach status and power to those roles in ways that harden into and continually reproduce patriarchy..
The chapter argued and thus this episode argues that biology mainly sets the terms for child-birth and breastfeeding, while nearly all of what we call “masculine” and “feminine” is socially produced through role dictates, rewards, and repeated training. That’s where the episode investigate mothering vs fathering as social roles, and why to assign nurturance to women and public power to men doesn’t only shape families, but also spills into work, politics, and culture. The episode then considers sexuality as a related political battleground, and names heterosexism and homophobia as structural forces that can cost people safety, jobs, housing, and even custody, and life itself, even beyond molding “opinions” and personal biases.
From there, this episode takes up a problem our survey of social spheres keeps encountering: monist theories that treat one sphere at the base of everything. We credit radical feminism’s sharp insights while we also push back on reductionism that in this case obscures or even erases class, race, and political power. The idea was not merely to criticize but to prepare the way for concepts able to highlight how kinship helps define other spheres of life and is in turn part defined by them.
The episode concludes, as do all others in this sequence, with a lively dialogue that puts diverse conflicts and issues on the table, including pornography, censorship, the fear that movements will splinter into endless faction fights, and more. The book's dialogues each include a diverse array of characters ranging from Marxist Leninist to Anarchist, Feminist to Nationalist, Socialist Feminist to Council Communist, and downright Cynical (who wants everyone to go home) to Complementary Holist (who represents and advocates the book's preferred stance). The idea this and indeed all the dialogues is for their human and sometimes pithy and sarcastic and other times impatient and funny exchanges to help us assess an emerging set of concepts and their connections to inform and also be informed by concepts and views addressing other defining spheres of social life all on the road to a new view of history and struggle to help us win a new world. The seven authors of Liberating Theory were Michael Albert, Leslie Cagan, Noam Chomsky, Robin Hahnel, Mel King, Lydia Sargent, and Holly Sklar.
Welcome And Series Context
SPEAKER_00Hello, my name is Michael Albert, and I am the host of the podcast that's titled Revolution Z. This is our 405th consecutive episode. It's titled Liberating Theory Gender. It continues a sequence taken from the book Liberating Theory, which seven writers activists collectively co-wrote. The seven authors were myself, Leslie Kagan, Noam Chomsky, Robin Hannel, Mel King, Lydia Sargent, and Holly Sklar. We got together to try to offer a liberated theory, liberated from past ideologies, that is. This episode excerpts chapter two of the book, which addressed gender and feminism.
Why No One Challenged The Critique
SPEAKER_00But before presenting that excerpted material, an observation. The prior what is to be undone part of the whole Revolution Z ideology sequence, which was delivered both as Revolution Z episodes and as articles on Zenet, went publicly unchallenged. That was, I have to admit, rather depressing. I presented and rejected classical Marxism, Leninism, and the Bolshevik Revolution as useful guides for activism. And like back in the distant past when that material was originally published, now too, there was no rejection of my rejection. No advocates of Marxism Leninism tore into my arguments to reveal their inadequacy, or, as one might have expected, what they would see as their utter delusional disassociated stupidity. No Marxists who proclaimed the virtues of what they call dialectics and historical materialism, for example, said that my rejection of both was a horrible deviation from revolutionary reason. No Leninists challenged, much less obliterated my account of Lenin's and Trotsky's Bolshevism and my derivative, aggressive rejection of Leninist strategy. At least no one did it publicly. Privately, I of course don't know. So I have to wonder, why has there been no critique? Yes, some, or maybe even all Marxist Leninists may have found my views absurd, ridiculous, or a kind of stupendous denial, more or less like if I had written an idiotic piece about aliens on the far side of the moon. And so they may have thought, okay, he's daft, but why rebut it? However, I think there is a big difference between the two posed approaches aliens on the other side of the moon and a critique of an existing ideology. That is, classical Marxists and Leninists are, like all political and social activists, concerned to advocate what is ideologically useful and to help people see through what is ideologically harmful. They are rarely even slightly reticent about defending their views, and are generally more than eager to pummel contrary views precisely because they feel contrary views are potentially harmful. But not in this case. Why not? I argued our need to transcend concepts and methods that many believe to be absolutely essential for effective activism. I did so quoting the sources of those views. So why didn't Marxist Leninists or even just Marxists rush to reject my rejection openly, in public? Why didn't those who think Marxism Leninism is an essential wisdom that we need to utilize to jump in to show why I was horrendously wrong? There is still time. Come on. Well, now I am offering a liberating theory based second part of the ideology sequence. Now it is not offering a critique, but a constructive alternative. Will folks who find the views offered dismal, deviant or deluded address them? I certainly hope so. Will folks who find the views interesting and even highly promising address them? I of course hope so. This is about the debits and virtues of theory, vision, and strategies we might use when working to stop Trump, stop fascism, stop ecological collapse, and move forward toward new fundamental kinship, cultural, political, and economic relations for a liberated future. Aren't those focuses, isn't that material worth attention? One way or the other?
Invitation To Debate And Engage
SPEAKER_00And if instead, but intimately related, you would rather consider a derivative, evocative, emotions, personality, ideas, interpersonal, activist centered account of what practice in our future in accord with these proposed concepts and methods might look like and accomplish, perhaps you will take a look at the new book, The Wind Cries Freedom, an oral history of the next American Revolution. It was not written decades ago by seven participants from that time, but is reported instead by nineteen participants from the future. They do not debate distant past ideas. They act on their liberated and liberating views and propose lessons learned from their future practice. I hope you will take a look.
Introducing Kinship As A Social Sphere
SPEAKER_00But for now, back to liberating theories next chapter that addresses society's kinship, gender, and sex relations. It starts in our framework from forty years ago, every society has a kinship sphere which significantly determines interactions among men, women and children. Kinship activity revolves around sexuality, procreation, child rearing, socialization, maturation, and aging. Where community, which we discussed last episode, focuses on language, art, ritual, and intercommunity relations, kinship focuses on the human life cycle and interpersonal relations. The resulting kin relations not only define sexual norms, but also how children are socialized to become adult lovers, mothers, fathers, wives, husbands, uncles, aunts, and so on. The kinship sphere thus sets role requirements for participation in sexual interaction and in socialization and also divides people into important gender groups, just as economic relations, for example, divide people into classes. I interject. Remember, please, that this was written forty years ago. Nonetheless, because it is at a very general level and regarding concepts, I hope it will prove useful now, albeit not complete. It was, I think, up to date, so to speak, at that time, regarding the essentials of feminist thinking. There has been more feminist thinking since, of course, but I think the underlying elements have persisted. At any rate, the book indicates how the seven authors then thought about kinship and views they were then eager to pursue as part of a larger conceptual toolbox that they hope to help compose to use in analyzing events and trends, developing vision and developing strategy. So the chapter continued.
Biology Versus Socially Made Gender
SPEAKER_00It is true we are born either male or female, and that biological differences alone determine who can and who cannot bear children and breastfeed. But in and of itself, the biological difference between being male and female determines little else. It does not determine how passive or aggressive we will be in sexual encounters. It does not determine whether we will be more attracted to members of the male or female sex. It does not determine whether we will be more we will be more proficient at nurturing others or at manipulating abstract concepts. It does not even alone determine one's height, weight, or density, although there are statistically significant differences between male and female averages in those areas. Nor does being male or female alone determine strength, speed, or endurance, although here too, even with other influences equal, we might find statistically significant differences in male and female averages. The point is that sexual biology dictates a particular quote division of labor in only two regards giving birth and breastfeeding. Beyond this, it has long since become an elementary truth, at least for informed critics of entrenched oppressive relations, that all gender relations are socially established. What's more, in every case where differences exist between what men and women do, including the bearing of children, the meanings given to these differences are socially defined. But let us investigate this a bit further. Socially created kin categories define particular roles in the social activity of reproduction, specify gender qualifications for filling the various roles, and most important, determine the social meaning and value associated with the different roles. The social relativity of all this must be recognized. For instance, what it means to be a quote father or a quote mother can differ from society to society. The kin category of quote godmother or maternal uncle may be important in one society, but not even defined in another. Even the degree to which quote blood relations mean more or less in a society depends on the extent to which important kinship functions are carried out by quote blood or quote non blood relatives. If, for example, children are reared by unrelated nannies or other surrogate caretakers, biological motherhood and fatherhood may be of reduced significance from the point of view of kinship roles. What it means to be quote heterosexual, quote homosexual, or quote bisexual, and whether it carries any broad social significance also varies from society to society. How people interact with one another in kinship activity is established by the kinship institutions of the institutional boundary and the patterns developed in the human center. Every society has a kinship structure in which people engage in kinship activity and interact within the contours of families, extended families, sexual communities, and subcommunities, and whatever other institutions exist in the kinship sphere. As a result, everyone identifies in part according to kin categories. We see ourselves as men or women, not always according to biological criteria, as having particular sexual preferences, and as being parent, child, sibling, or grandparent. Each identification affects how we view ourselves and other people and what needs and interests we develop. To the extent that kinship categories differ in different societies, the pattern of interests and needs they generate will vary as well. There is almost nothing genetic about all this. Since no specific role pattern and no particular rule of sexual assignment is biologically determined, each society must determine roles and assignments through a social process. For this reason, we can justifiably ask whether any particular set of kinship relations promotes equitable and fulfilling human socialization or whether it restricts people's ability to fulfill all that their biological potential allows. Kinship relations are not quote God given or quote nature given, but historical. If a particular set fulfills us, we can celebrate its virtues. If a particular set oppresses us, we can struggle to change them.
Defining Patriarchy And Sexism
SPEAKER_00In spite of the many different kinds of kinship relations that have existed in different societies, there has been a remarkable continuity regarding a few important features of most kinship systems of which we have any knowledge. Since one critical kind of domination relation that has plagued human history is the domination of men over women, patriarchy, or male supremacy, has appeared as a key feature of most kinship systems to date. Patriarchy is the name for any kinship system in which the role divisions between gender groups grant fewer duties and more benefits from kinship activity to men than women. Sexism refers broadly to the mindset and behavior associated with and supporting patriarchy. In the words of Adrian Rich, quoted earlier, quote, patriarchy is the power of the fathers, a familial, social, ideological, political system, in which men, by force, direct pressure, or through ritual, tradition, law and language, customs, etiquette, education, and the division of labor, determine what part women shall or shall not play, and in which the female is everywhere subsumed under the male. Under patriarchy I may live in perda or drive a truck. I may serve my husband his early morning coffee within the clay walls of a Berber village or march in an academic procession. Whatever my status or situation, my derived economic class or my sexual preference, I live under the power of the fathers, and I have access only to so much privilege or influence as the patriarchy is willing to accede to me, and only for as long as I will pay the price for male approval. Labeling a society patriarchal tells us that its gender relations are oppressive to women while they give power to men. Kate Millet writes, quote, our society, like all other historical civilizations, is a patriarchy. The fact is evident at once if one recalls that the military, industry, technology, universities, science, political office, and finance, in short, every avenue of power within the society, including the coercive force of the police, is in male hands. But to label a society patriarchal is not comprehensive. The label fits most historical kinship forms, just as the label quote class divided applies to feudal slave, capitalist, and quote state socialist economies. Calling a society quote patriarchal tells us that men dominate women, but little about the particular forms and mechanisms this relationship takes. To do better, we need more refined concepts to distinguish different types of patriarchy, just as the concepts feudal and capitalist distinguish different types of class divided societies. But to date, feminists do not agree about how to make these finer distinctions, and we will not attempt to do so here. Patriarchal societies are characterized universally by a sexual division of labor and reward. This division has many elements of varying impact. For example, inheritance is generally man centered. Women generally take men's names when they marry, women generally do less public tasks, women's rewards in the form of wages and status are lower than men's, sexual expect expectations are differentiated, and so on. But most important in the analyses of many feminists is that in patriarchal societies women quote mother and men quote father.
Mothering, Fathering, And Power
SPEAKER_00Though this difference may seem obvious, of course women mother, mothers are women, of course men father, fathers are men. The fact of the matter is that quote mothering and quote fathering are social roles that both men and women are biologically capable of fulfilling. Mothering and fathering are two aspects of quote parenting, which have been divided from one another and gender identified to enforce social and personality divisions that would otherwise be absent. Why men do not often mother and why women do not often father must be explained by social and historical reasons. In traditional terms, mother means the female parent, but to mother means to provide nurturance and to care for and care about. To mother means to see the tasks of cleaning, loving, and teaching a child as one's personal priority, and to organize one's life in large part around their successful accomplishment. Mothering is a full time job. By equating mother and female and to mother and a particular set of responsibilities and inclinations, our use of words says that women are by nature inclined toward certain types of what we then label feminine behaviors. In contrast, in traditional terms, father means the male parent, but to father refers to a modest role that involves disciplining, playing, and sometimes teaching. Fathering doesn't require constant attentiveness and is not nearly so central to one's identity as mothering. One fathers a few minutes or hours a day, and frequently not for days at a time. To father is never more than a part-time job. Identifying men with father and father with these limited responsibilities only minimally augments our understanding of what men are. This view says that men are by nature inclined towards certain types of what we then label masculine behaviors, which are socially assertive and outgoing, but with the nurturant element sublimated. Moreover, these divisions are communicated to children as well. As Nancy Choderot argues in the Reproduction of Mothering, I interject a book worth looking at, even though forty years ago. And men whose nurture and capacities have been suppressed. The sexual and familiar division of labor in which women mother and are more involved in interpersonal, affective relationships produces in daughters and sons a division of psychological capacities, which leads them to reproduce this division of labor. Yet none of this is biologically inevitable. It is perfectly possible to conceive of a society where women father and men mother, or preferably, in which women and men both parent. Likewise, the social status and power derived from mothering, fathering, or parenting is not inherent in the roles themselves, but results from social factors. There is nothing inconceivable about a society in which women only mother and in which men only father, maintaining a gender division of labor, but in which it is women who garner higher status and social power than men from this difference, thus reversing the order of the hierarchy. However, as biologically feasible as the above possibilities might be, none have occurred frequently, or perhaps even at all in the human history that we know. And the discovery that females quote mother and males quote father in all known patriarchal societies is highly suggestive. One foundation for male domination of women is probably the binding of women to mothering, which frees men to focus their attention on non household activities that are in turn awarded greater social status. And even beyond freeing men from more valued social activities, the different psychological dynamics of mothering and fathering produce profound differences between the psychologies of men and women. These in turn have broad implications for the ability of men and women to achieve social recognition in a patriarchal society. The personality traits corresponding to mothering and fathering become equated with what it is to be a man or a woman in a society where women mother and men father. Thus one basis for differential esteem in all social roles, not just the roles of mothering and fathering, is their relative demand for personality traits associated with mothering or fathering. It follows then that even when mothers get out of the home, they are seriously handicapped. handicapped in competing for esteemed roles in patriarchal societies. In this way, the asymmetry between men's and women's parenting roles extends to the entire social division of labor. In patriarchal societies, some tasks are deemed female and others male. Female tasks include cleaning, tidying, cooking, serving, and certain forms of exhibitionism, which all then appear to be as deserving of low esteem as the job of wife and mother they resemble. Male tasks include making war, governing, and producing whatever are considered the more important economic goods in the more serious and quote important ways. Women might be allowed to succeed not only as mothers and housekeepers, but also in other sexually defined roles like nurses, teachers, actresses or models. The specific sexual division of labor may differ from society to society and generation to generation, but women dominated fields are by are by definition lower status. For example, in the United States bank tellers and clerks had much higher status before they became female dominated fields, with clerks transformed into secretaries. In the Soviet Union, the majority of doctors are women but the status of the field is relatively low in some, the differential human consequences of mothering and fathering and their full social extension, rather than any important biological differences between the sexes, can result in more or less differentiated male and female modes of existence, how we perceive and interact with the world, the kind of emotions we have, and the extent to which we relate to them, and even the way we walk and talk can all come to depend on whether we adhere to the male or female mode of being. It follows that in order to help activists properly understand any society, it is essential that among other accomplishments liberating theory provides concepts able to reveal the ways in which men's and women's lives differ, and if patriarchy is present, what its implications are, and how it is enforced and reproduced.
Heterosexism, Homophobia, And Control
SPEAKER_00And in that light, an additional critical dimension of kinship relations and manifestations of patriarchy has to do with sexuality and sexual preference. Heterosexism is the oppression of gays and lesbians in the belief that heterosexuality is superior to homosexuality. Homophobia refers specifically to anger at the dread of homosexuality, but is also used loosely to define heterosexist behavior, subtle or overt in the homosexualization of America, Dennis Altman writes quote, it is not uncommon to hear calls for castration and even the death penalty for homosexuals among some fundamentalists. The language of homophobia is remarkable for its vehemence Why was homosexuality and not rape or murder long seen as quote the unmentionable and abominable crime? And its frequency, Anglo Celtic slang in particular, is full of references to homosexuality. Cocksucker, bugger, pansy, faggot, poofter are all common terms of abuse is striking, as if the constant reiteration of homosexual words and references would somehow ward off the reality. Most clearly homophobes constantly speak as if homosexuality were contagious and place great stress on protecting children from any contact with homosexuals. It is hard to explain logically how homosexuality can at the same time be quote disgusting and unnatural, and yet so attractive that only the most severe sanctions will prevent its becoming rampant. In coming out, gay men and lesbians may risk bodily harm, gay bashing and rape, involuntary hospitalization in a mental institution, excommunication by the church, rejection by friends and family, dismissal from the job, eviction and since another manifestation of heterosexism is the idea that gay men and lesbians do not and should not have children, loss of custody of children. Lesbian mothers in particular have fought and lost many a custody bottle with former male spouses. In Boston in nineteen eighty five, two gay male foster parents had their foster children removed from their care and the Massachusetts state legislature passed a bill that ensures the surviving partners of gay couples who have children may find that they have no parental rights with the death of the biological or adoption parent, even if they have been named the legal guardian. In the United States homophobia and heterosexism cross all community lines. Black nationalists have variously defined homosexuality as a white man's disease, a decadent manifestation of cultural decay or genocide. Sherry Moraga writes of both sexism and heterosexism within Chicano culture and La Familia quote, we believe the more severely we protect the sex roles within the family, the stronger we will be as a unit in opposition to the Anglo threat. Living under capitalist patriarchy, what is true for quote the man in terms of misogyny is to a great extent true for the Chicano. He too, like any other man, wants to be able to determine how, when and with whom his women, mother, wife and daughter are sexual. For without male imposed sexual and legal control of our reproductive freedom reinforced by the Catholic Church and the social institutionalization of our roles as sexual and domestic servants to men, Chicanas might very frequently choose to do otherwise, including being sexually independent from and or with men. In fact, the forced choice of the gender of our sexual love partner seems to precede the forced choice of the form marriage and family that partnership might take. The control of women begins through the institution of heterosexuality end quote I interject remember this book was published in nineteen eighty six, a year after some of the events that are referenced and at the time of these writings the chapter continues understanding the relationships that define sexuality and people's reactions to different sexual preferences is part of understanding the basic defining relations of any society. Later we will return to this issue to ask whether the concept of a quote kinship sphere provides a sufficient starting point for these necessary analyses, or whether instead we need to introduce still another basic defining sphere of social life based on sexuality itself. All feminists agree that the kinship sphere radiates important influences which pervade all other aspects of social life. Feminists recognize that work, politics and cultural activity are always carried out by people who are gender defined, so that the patriarchal division of society doesn't stop at the bedroom or kitchen door. Feminists note how the differences between men and women's appointed kinship activities generate different presuppositions about who they are and about what their attitudes and behaviors will be, which then affect all their activity. And feminists challenge the assumption that some kinds of jobs are quote naturally suited to men and others to women, arguing that the differential rewards they receive are not simply the quote natural outcome of competitive market forces.
Critiquing Feminist Monism And Reductionism
SPEAKER_00But quote, radical feminists have gone further and transformed their insights into a sex-based monus theory, in which the kinship sphere is presumed to dominate all other aspects of social life. For radical feminists the kinship sphere becomes quote base and all else quote superstructure. Patriarchal domination and gender struggle becomes the fundamental differentiation against which all other social differentiations must be interpreted. As Robin Morgan expressed the view quote sexism is the root oppression, the one which until and unless we uproot it will continue to put forth the branches of racism, class hatred, ageism, competition, ecological disaster and economic exploitation. No other human differentiations can be similarly powerful in reproducing oppressions, and so Morgan concluded women are the real left Shulamith Firestone summarizes the radical feminist position by paraphrasing angles she says feminist materialism she's paraphrasing, putting in feminism Feminist materialism is that view of history which seeks the ultimate cause and the great moving power of all historic events in the dialectics of sex, the division of society into two distinct biological classes for procreative reproduction, and the struggles of these classes in changes in the modes of marriage reproduction and childcare, in the first division of labor based on sex, and in the connected development of other physically differentiated classes castes which develop into the economic cultural class system. I interject Firestone was making a case that in the same way that people think about class that Marxists and Marxist Leninists think about class, one could think about gender. It's not clear to me that she was saying we ought to it may be that she was just trying to debunk, let's call it, the idea of one sphere dominating all others. In any event that's what came forth in liberating theory The chapter continues despite the fact that some of the sharpest insights of the feminist movement have come from radical feminism, the reductionist premise radical feminism involves is no more justified or less debilitating than the reductionist premise of cultural nationalism discussed last chapter. Radical feminists underestimate the importance of other spheres of social activity and other forms of domination. They overlook the profound influence of other spheres of social life on kinship relations themselves. They often over exaggerate the influence of kinship relations on the rest of society. Radical feminists underestimate the extent to which a working class woman, for example, is affected by her class experience as well as her gender experience. Radical feminists also minimize the extent to which the gender experience of a working class woman is different from the gender experience of an upper class woman. Similarly a black lesbian has both racial and gender experiences that differ substantially from those of a white lesbian. Yet all these differences are obscured by a monus feminist framework. To deal with them it is essential that feminist concepts leave room to incorporate influences from other spheres of social life. Feminists rightly assert that history is a history of gender struggle, both because gender divisions are the basis of a primary domination relations and because gender norms permeate class political and cultural relations. But we have already argued that history is a history of community struggle and we will soon see that it is equally true that history is a history of class struggle and a history of political struggle for precisely the same reasons that it is a history of gender struggle. There is nothing inconsistent in these claims instead it is a myopic monist viewpoint that makes complementary insights appear incompatible and undermines the possibility of solidarity among diverse movements with different primary agendas. A rightful feminist critique of the ways that other monist approaches neglect gender can wrongly grow into dismissal of the importance of other facets of left thought and practice as for example in the following passage from Adrian Rich for many of us the word revolution itself has become not only a dead relic of leftism but a key to the deadness of male politics the revolution of a wheel which returns in the end to the same place the revolving door of a politics which has liberated women only to use them and only within the limits of male tolerance end quote to develop a working liberating theory in coming chapters we must incorporate the insights of feminism into a broader conceptual framework which retains the integrity of gender focus and equally highlights the impact of forces from other spheres throughout society and within kinship as well.
Measuring Kinship By Human Flourishing
SPEAKER_00Depending on the particular pattern of kinship institutions and relations sexual needs can be developed and molded in different ways, leading to more or less satisfaction or frustration and children can be socialized to different patterns of adult roles through different systems of assigned duties, obligations and prerogatives characterized by more or less repression of their potential. So every kinship system implies not only quote how does it work questions, but quote how well does it work questions too? How well does the system develop and satisfy human sexual potentials? How little of children's initiative and creativity is repressed in the process of socialization? It is true men are pressured to narrow their psychological development to accord with a patriarchal of definition of what a man should be, specifically stunting nurturing capacities and ways of relating to their own emotions, other people and even the physical universe as they hone their masculinity. So it is also true that patriarchy entails a loss of potential sexual and social satisfaction for all men. But as we found when we but as we found when examining the consequences of racism for dominant and subordinate communities, patriarchy suppression and warping of human potentials is not symmetrical for men and women. As in all domination relations, although both parties are disfigured, the greatest burden of the system falls clearly on the subordinate group, in this case women in general, the young, the old, gay men and lesbians. But kinship structures are not frozen in time. Kinship systems can be thought of as kinds of dissipative systems, in which alterations in institutional roles and human characteristics are most often quote damped in Prigergine's sense to remain within defining norms. Disruptive pressures can come from without for example when a war draws more women into the workforce new economic products inundate the household with electronic gadgets or religious upheavals lead to changes in cultural definitions that throw gender definitions into question as well. Or pressure for change can come from within for example when new means of birth control radically alter the consequences of sexual activities or when youth rebellion stemming from changing family patterns alter socialization processes. But these are matters we address in coming chapters on society and history. Lastly in comparing the kinship sphere to the community sphere and later to economics and politics we should recognize that each has pervasive influences on social life. Each defines critical social divisions among people. Each generates critical psychological differences between people and each has roots in institutional and psychological aspects of society that influence one another and are influenced by other aspects of society as well. Each influences the other and is influenced by the other and so each affects history in a complex pattern we will better understand as we proceed.
Roundtable Clash On Theory And Strategy
SPEAKER_00So ended chapter three of Liberating theory here however we included the dialogue which in the book appeared only at the end of the whole volume. This dialogue begins with Koho, the complimentary holistic advocate summing up the kinship category Every society has a socially determined kinship sphere which determines interactions between men and women, the nature of sexuality, child bearing, socialization and procreation, the character of kinship spheres changes over time and interacts with and are influenced by economic, political and community spheres. Marlin, still eager to begin, as usual, replies I am glad to see Koho, that you are aware of the propound weaknesses in current feminist thinking. I've read much of their literature and while sensitive to their cause, I have always argued against the ahical character of feminism. Patriarchy is a constant throughout time. Gender dynamics are the motor force of history. Come on they call me economistic and sex blind but their theory makes them totally blind to class differences. Nate adds significantly Marlin you left out the racist nature of feminism. Most feminist analysis in the literature I've read uses the term women the way you Marlin use the term working man. You're both describing the experience of white women and white working men. You don't address different circumstances for women in different communities to use Koho's construct. You'll never convince women of color that feminists have any real interest in such analyses. Anna responds Significantly Nate you failed to mention that feminism has contributed much to the discussion and practice on non hierarchical relations and processes. However feminism has also failed I think to pay enough attention to the political sphere to use Koho's concept. A great deal of feminism idolizes female traits and argues for a separate superior status through institutionalized matriarchies. C C, the Council Communist reacts besides I just can't see sexuality as a basic part of social theory. When parts of the women's movement start arguing for homosexuality as the norm or for heterosexuality as the root of all evil, they leave me behind. Or the other extreme is to elevate motherhood while denigrating lesbianism. To me the nature of sexuality in a society is determined by economic and political structures. Anna follows most authoritarian societies repress sexuality, legislate quote normal sex, and legislate against homosexuality Sophie, the socialist feminist wondering why she has to listen to all this again, adds that does it I hardly know where to begin. Her eyes search the room finding Morlin Morlin, your concern for history would be more compelling if you bothered to notice the historical development of thinking in the current women's movement. Many women are attempting to conceptualize the different forms patriarchy has taken throughout predominantly male written history and what's so historical about your claims about class struggle you don't even look at the change in composition of the working class concept of you worship nor do you look at the changes based on gender conflict or race conflict. Besides while your concern for the working class is touching what, as Koho has indicated, quote socialist society is run by the working class are you really concerned with my ahistoricity or with the possibility that you may be dethroned and by women no less Rad Fem on her feet adds I find your concern for the flight of black women just a bit hypocrisy Hypocritical. And if, Nate, you think sexism is a white male construct, and if you think that white culture is so despicable, why then do you copy this sexist construct? Sophie adds, and as a black woman, I participated in black power organizations, and the oppression of black women in those movements belies the sincerity of your concern. Am I going too fast for you? Rad Fem and C C, I am touched by your comments and support around sexuality and homophobia which has caused the persecution and deaths of large portions of history's gay communities. Sophie and Anna, while I respect the anarchist tradition, I just don't see how your exclusive focus on authoritarianism is going to help you understand gender differences. If parents are defined generally as authoritarian, what helps you look at the difference between the mother and the father? Rad Fem, not to be denied. And Koho, you focus on biological differences as if even mentioning them will result in fascism. Excuse me, but men and women are different biologically. We could debate genes and sizes of brains and other such sociobiology concerns, but they only obscure the fact that women have babies. Your theory leads to a culturally imposed, bisexual, androgynous society. I think there is a male and a female principle, which have roots in biology, and that one principle is caring and the other prone to violence. Yes, men can sublimate their maleness, but I think women have got to gain greater influence than men so that the male principle can be kept under control. Sophie, taken aback. Now hold on, Radfam. I accept the need to explore the concepts of mothering, fathering, and so on, but I cannot accept a society where quote nature as nurture is the watchword. Your concepts applied to all of society relegate men to a form of testosterone dominated beasthood. You never accepted men's biological arguments for women's inferiority. Why repeat their mistake by pull by flipping that record over? Your concepts still don't help explain why women were oppressed in the first place. Why should bearing children make women subordinate? Rad Fem. But your dualistic combining of Marxism and feminism has no room for understanding sexuality and sexual preference as crucial for female liberation. In fact, they have no place in your homophobic materialistic approach. Coho happy to expand this point, responds. There is something in what both of you say. But Radfemm, by asserting a biological approach, you must also assert that women naturally nurture, since in your construct all female defined activities have become positive, you lead women right back toward monopolizing child rearing and other similar work. It's as if we have moved from seeking liberation to trying to redefine our oppression as liberation itself. Moreover, the biological differences argument can lead to other problems. Radfemm. Like what?
Pornography, Censorship, And Sexual Agency
SPEAKER_00Coho, let's apply the biological differences focus to the current heated issue of pornography. If men are responsible for all the suppressive in society, then pornography is one of the ways in which men maintain the patriarchy, that is, through the threat and practice of violence, particularly sexual violence against women and children. What course of action does this analysis require of feminists? Radfem eliminate the entire pornography industry along with rape. Coho and all forms of sexual dominance. Rad Fem, you won't get me to say that. Coho. But you must admit that those kinds of conclusions are inherent to the biological differences argument, and I just can't go along with it. While I agree that my theory and my theory reflects this, that in a sexist society and in a sexually repressed society and in a homophobic society, the free expression of sexuality is difficult if not impossible. I cannot agree that pornography, which I define as literature, art or photography of erotic or sexual acts intended to excite intended to excite lustful feelings, is inherently evil. That would be like saying because the economy is a male construct and promotes sexism, we should eliminate economics. Marlin says I'm beginning to be impressed, Koho. Coho. It's the same thing with spirituality. Because most religions are oppressive in some way does not mean we should do away with spirituality. Marlin reacts, you lost me. Koho, this is why I continue to argue vehemently against Monas theories. They lead you, Radfem, to ignore the liberatory possibilities of pornography and involve you in alliances with people who are homophobic and orotophobic, and they require you to engage in authoritarian struggles around censorship. Anna responds, I'm appalled. Rad Fem, I begin to see what Mona's thinking can lead to, but I don't think you're aware of the dangers of your concepts. They lead you to sacrifice serious attention to violence against women on the altar of a liberal concern for a non existent freedom of speech. Toho, I don't think so. I pursue an end to violence against women without denying that women's and men's sexual needs and desires are critical to developing a liberatory society or overlooking the dangers of censorship. If that can be done, why should you object? Radfem, because I don't think it's possible. Sophie, I sometimes feel that men will always hold to their own self interest. Sin reacts from their from the corner. Excuse me, but Nate interrupts. I knew something was missing from this discussion. Sin or Cynic, more long suffering than ever, says I think it is safe to say that each discussion helped builds my case. It's never going to be possible for you all to respect each other's concerns. You can develop the most sensitive theory, coho, but when it comes to practice, Morlin's going to identify with economics and the working class, paying lip service to your other spheres. Ratfim will do the same for gender, and so on. Endless fighting until we wear each other down or all give up and become sectarian from the resulting cynicism. I know, I've been there. Koho replies, so have I. We've all been there, but you see only those who have become cynical. What about those who haven't? Besides, do you want to wallow in it forever? Sophie, not me. Rad Fem, do we have a choice? Nate, wallowing is not part of my human nature. Anna, nor mine. Koho. And on that note, let's move to the economic sphere. Morlin on the edge of his seat. Finally, the others exchange looks as Morlin watches Koho rustle through her papers. So ends the discussion following chapter two.
Why Revisit These Ideas Now
SPEAKER_00I hope it's becoming clear what the seven authors were trying to do forty years ago. In a short, accessible work, they tried to survey some areas of revolutionary thought so far, community and gender, and still to come economy and polity, to discern the virtues and debits of the existing conceptualizations. Then they would continue on to try to remove weaknesses and add worthy, hopeful additional insights. Their aim was to offer an accessible conceptual toolbox suited to activist inclinations, existing relations, future desires, and means to reach them, a new ideology, if you will. In the forty years since, some of what they propose lived on widely, some only very narrow. So why am I offering it all in our time? Partly for a time travel look into where we were, but mostly in the belief that the concepts and methods offered then and still to emerge in coming episodes can spur discussion leading to refinements and applications suitable now.
Sign Off And Next Topic Economy
SPEAKER_00And all that said, this is Michael Albert, a cohoian, signing off for Revolution Z until next time, when the topic broadly scrutinized for guiding insights becomes economy.